Essay

Five Years to Say “We Were Wrong”

Christina Applegate's reported misdiagnosis raises an uncomfortable question: when medical treatment isn't producing the expected results, who takes responsibility for questioning the original assumptions? Medical mistakes are sometimes unavoidable. But years of following the wrong path need not be. This article explores diagnostic anchoring, the value of independent clinical oversight, and why having a Medical Fiduciary firmly in your corner could make all the difference.

Five Years to Say “We Were Wrong”
Medical mistakes happen. But who makes sure we don't keep making the same one?

Five years.

That's how long Christina Applegate lived with a diagnosis of multiple sclerosis before her doctors reportedly concluded that it was incorrect.

Five years of treatment, medical consultations, and living with a serious neurological diagnosis.

And then, apparently, it wasn't MS after all.

Now, before anyone reaches for the pitchforks, let's establish something.

Medicine is difficult. Even excellent physicians make mistakes. Diseases imitate one another, symptoms overlap, and sometimes the evidence leads us down the wrong road.

I've spent enough years in medicine to know that certainty is not something you can order from the pharmacy.

Nor do I intend to criticise Christina Applegate's doctors. We don't know her complete medical history, and there may be perfectly legitimate reasons why the diagnosis took so long to reconsider.

But I keep coming back to one question.

Five years?

Not because I know it could have been corrected sooner. I don't.

But because it raises a much bigger question:

Who is responsible for noticing when the story no longer fits?

Imagine being treated for a condition over several years. Your symptoms persist. Perhaps they worsen. The treatment isn't producing the expected results.

Now, that doesn't automatically mean the diagnosis is wrong. Some treatments prevent deterioration rather than reverse existing damage. Multiple sclerosis is a good example.

But shouldn't someone occasionally ask whether the original explanation still makes sense?

Medicine even has a name for the tendency to stick with an established diagnosis: *diagnostic anchoring*.

Once we've decided what something is, new information tends to be interpreted through that decision.

A bit like buying a red car and suddenly seeing red cars everywhere.

Except that in medicine, the consequences can be considerably less entertaining.

And reconsidering diagnoses is hardly unusual.

A systematic review published in Mayo Clinic Proceedings found that between 10% and 62% of second opinions resulted in major changes to diagnosis, treatment or prognosis, depending on the population studied. These were selected patients seeking second opinions, not a representative sample of all medical care. [2]

That doesn't mean half of all doctors are wrong. It means that when cases are reviewed, changing course is far from extraordinary.

The diagnosis is supposed to follow the evidence. Not the other way around.

So who makes sure that happens?

Usually, the treating physician. Sometimes another specialist. Occasionally, the patient who has finally had enough and decides to seek another opinion.

Which is rather an extraordinary expectation.

You're sick, frightened, perhaps exhausted, and struggling to understand what's happening to your body.

And apparently, you're also expected to recognise when your doctors should reconsider their conclusions.

Wonderful. Another full-time job.

This is where I believe modern healthcare is missing something fundamental.

A Medical Fiduciary.

Not another superstar specialist. Not someone who knows more about MS than the neurologist who has spent thirty years studying it.

And certainly not someone hired to argue with doctors. There are easier ways to make enemies.

A Medical Fiduciary is a dedicated clinical advocate whose responsibility is to protect the patient's best interests throughout their healthcare journey.

Someone who knows the patient's story, understands the treatment objectives, follows the progress, and notices when things aren't adding up.

Someone prepared to ask:

"Are we seeing the results we expected?"

"Does the diagnosis still explain what's happening?"

"Should we reconsider our assumptions?"

Not accusations. Just questions.

But questions asked at the right moment can change the direction of an entire medical journey.

And unlike a second opinion, which is usually requested at a particular point, this responsibility is continuous.

A Medical Fiduciary doesn't need to be the smartest person in the room.

They need to be the person who makes sure the room never loses sight of the patient.

Would such an approach have changed Christina Applegate's experience?

We cannot know.

Perhaps the diagnosis could have been questioned earlier. Perhaps not.

But her story illustrates something we should take seriously.

Doctors are human. They make mistakes. They can become attached to their conclusions, just like the rest of us.

The difference is that in medicine, the price of being wrong can be exceptionally high.

Five years may sometimes be unavoidable.

But five years without someone taking responsibility for asking whether we're still on the right path?

That should never be the default.

And that's precisely why I believe in the Medical Fiduciary.

Not someone whose job is to fight your doctors.

Someone whose job is to stand firmly in your corner.

---

References

[1] Christina Applegate's reported misdiagnosis

Associated Press, 20 October 2026. *Christina Applegate says her doctor told her she was misdiagnosed with MS.*

https://apnews.com/article/767e4e74de36f5f98fcd44e201016aee

BBC News, 20 October 2026. *Christina Applegate says she was wrongly diagnosed with MS.*

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cqlyel3wnxmxo

[2] Second opinions and changes in clinical decisions

*Patient-initiated second opinions: systematic review of characteristics and impact on diagnosis, treatment, and satisfaction.*

Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 2014.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24797646/

← All Insights & Media