Lost in the best hands. Part III
Congratulations! Your CT scan is perfectly normal. Naturally, you'll need another one. Different specialist. Different protocol. A little more contrast. Just to be thorough. After all, why listen to a patient's entire story when you can investigate every organ separately? Modern medicine has extraordinary diagnostic tools. Sometimes, what we're missing is someone who knows which ones NOT to use. Lost in the Best Hands — Part III. The curious art of collecting medical investigations.
The curious art of collecting CT scans, MRIs and other medical souvenirs.
Congratulations! Your doctors have found absolutely nothing wrong with you.
Naturally, you'll need another CT scan.
Perhaps with contrast this time. A slightly wider field of view. A few additional blood tests, just to be on the safe side.
After all, you wouldn't want to miss anything.
Welcome to one of modern medicine's more peculiar hobbies: collecting investigations.
Some people collect watches, art, vintage cars, or expensive bottles of wine that nobody is ever allowed to drink.
Others collect CT scans, MRIs, ultrasounds and laboratory results.
Some have collections impressive enough to require their own cloud storage subscription.
And they're often rather proud of them.
“Look how thorough my doctors are!”
Well, yes. They certainly seem to be keeping the radiology department busy and the blood-testing laboratories thriving.
Don't misunderstand me. Modern diagnostic technology is extraordinary. I've spent much of my professional life watching medicine become capable of seeing and measuring things that would have been unimaginable a generation ago.
But the ability to look for something doesn't necessarily mean we should.
And having the best doctors doesn't automatically mean that someone is looking at the bigger picture.
Imagine you've developed persistent abdominal discomfort.
Your GP orders blood tests and an ultrasound. Nothing alarming appears, but the symptoms continue, so you're referred to a gastroenterologist.
The gastroenterologist requests a CT scan. Fair enough. There may be a good reason.
A few weeks later, you consult another specialist. A highly regarded one, naturally. You've heard he's the best.
He wants another set of blood tests and another CT scan.
“Didn't I already have a CT?”
“Yes, but I'd like to investigate this properly. We need to extend the area of imaging and add a specific contrast protocol.”
Ah. Properly. Such a reassuring word when you're paying several hundred pounds for a consultation.
Three months later, you're carrying a folder containing more images of your abdomen than your family has photographs of you.
Perhaps every investigation was justified.
Perhaps some weren't.
But did anyone actually stop to read the previous reports, compare the findings, and understand what had already been ruled out?
Or did everyone start from the beginning, as though you had arrived fresh from the factory?
Here's the thing.
A good investigation begins long before anyone orders a test.
It begins with a conversation.
Not the seven-minute version where you're interrupted halfway through explaining why you came.
A proper conversation.
Someone listens to your story from beginning to end. Asks when the symptoms started, what makes them better or worse, what happened before they appeared, what medications you're taking, and what else has changed in your life.
Someone asks the questions you didn't realise were relevant.
And, perhaps most importantly, someone knows you.
Your history. Your previous illnesses. Your family. Your habits. Your worries. What is normal for you and what isn't.
This isn't nostalgia for medicine practised with a leather bag and a stethoscope.
It's clinical reasoning.
Studies have long demonstrated that a substantial proportion of diagnoses can be suggested by taking a careful medical history, often before the physical examination and investigations are completed.
Think about that.
We have machines capable of producing extraordinary images of the human body, yet one of our most powerful diagnostic tools remains a physician who knows how to listen.
A good clinical history doesn't always provide the diagnosis.
But it often provides something almost as valuable: a short, sensible list of what the diagnosis might be.
We call it a differential diagnosis.
And once that list is short enough, choosing the right investigations becomes a different exercise altogether.
Instead of ordering fifteen tests to see what turns up, you order the two or three that will help distinguish between the most likely explanations.
Or sometimes none, because the history and examination have already answered the question.
Of course, urgent symptoms and serious warning signs may demand immediate, broader investigation. Good judgement includes knowing when not to wait.
But indiscriminate testing isn't the same thing as thorough medicine.
It's a bit like trying to shoot a duck with a machine gun.
You'll probably hit the duck.
Unfortunately, you'll also take out half the wildlife around it and spend a fortune on ammunition.
Very thorough shooting, though.
Medicine has its own version of the collateral damage.
An incidental finding on a scan leads to another scan. A borderline blood result triggers a specialist referral. Something harmless acquires a diagnostic label, followed by months of surveillance.
Sometimes these findings matter enormously.
Sometimes they are simply consequences of looking everywhere for everything.
And then there's the duplication.
The same blood tests repeated because the previous results weren't available. Imaging ordered again because the new specialist hasn't seen the original study. Investigations performed without anyone checking whether they will add information or change treatment.
I've seen this happen hundreds of times.
It's wasteful, occasionally harmful, and remarkably easy to mistake for excellent care.
Because every doctor involved may be competent. Every investigation may look reasonable when viewed in isolation.
The problem is that nobody has necessarily examined the entire sequence.
That's where the wide perspective matters.
Someone who has the time to hear your story, the knowledge to understand it, and the continuity to remember what has already happened.
Someone who reads the reports before requesting another one.
Someone who knows when a second opinion is valuable and when a second investigation is simply a repetition of the first.
Someone who can ask the most useful question in the entire process:
“What exactly are we trying to find out, and will this test help us find it?”
It's not about doing fewer investigations for the sake of doing fewer.
It's about doing the right ones.
Because the best healthcare isn't necessarily the healthcare that gives you access to every available diagnostic machine.
It's the healthcare that knows which machine you actually need.
Before sending you to any machine at all, it starts by pulling up a chair and listening.