Lost in the Best Hands — Part II.
Private doctors. A personal trainer. A prestigious weight-loss clinic. And a complimentary kidney failure. Not quite the wellness package my friend had in mind. But when every specialist focuses on their own piece of the puzzle, nobody necessarily notices what the whole picture is becoming.
Lost in the Best Hands — Part II
Jim
A very good friend of mine lives in New York. Let’s call him Jim.
Jim is in his 50s, sits in a CEO chair for two decades now.
He’s a bit overweight, prediabetic for years, and has high blood pressure.
Nothing too exotic. These days, a belly and hypertension seem almost a prerequisite for membership in certain private business clubs.
His internal medicine consultant put him on treatment. Good doctor, sensible prescriptions. Nothing to complain about.
Jim then decided that medication alone wasn’t enough. He was going to get fit.
He hired a personal trainer and started exercising. A lot.
Now, when you’ve spent years treating physical activity as something other people do, your body tends to have an opinion about suddenly becoming an athlete.
Jim’s opinionated body started hurting.
So he bought some painkillers over the counter.
The back pain improved, but then other parts started hurting. Jim went to see an orthopaedic surgeon. A knee specialist. One of the best in New York.
The surgeon had seen worse knees before breakfast. He prescribed a very potent anti-inflammatory. For ten days.
Parallel to training, Jim had to tackle his weight. He went to a prestigious lifestyle clinic, the kind that promises to turn you into a healthier version of yourself, provided your credit card survives the experience.
They gave him supplements, vitamins, and a weight-loss remedy.
Among its ingredients was furosemide, a powerful diuretic.
Jim was pleased. His blood pressure was being treated. His joints hurt less. He was exercising and losing weight.
He had assembled a fine collection of professionals, all working on improving Jim.
A week later, Jim developed acute kidney failure.
Not quite the improvement he’d had in mind.
Now, there’s a well-known medical problem involving certain blood pressure medications, anti-inflammatory drugs, and diuretics. Combine them, and you can seriously compromise kidney function.
Jim had been prediabetic for years, which may already have affected the small blood vessels in his kidneys. Hypertension adds another layer of risk.
The anti-inflammatory drugs, the blood pressure treatment, and the furosemide were a combination his kidneys could have done without.
None of this required a rare disease, an exotic complication, or negligent practitioner.
It required several people treating different parts of the same man without knowing enough about what everyone else was doing.
And here’s the part that bothers me most.
Jim wasn’t hiding anything. He wasn’t trying to outsmart his doctors. He wanted to get healthier and was prepared to invest time, money, and effort into doing so.
Yet nobody had stopped to ask him one of the most basic questions in medicine:
The medical version of “Are you seeing other people” …? and “what are they giving you”?
Not just prescription drugs. The pills from the pharmacy. The vitamins. The supplements. The powder recommended by a trainer. The weight-loss remedy from the fashionable clinic.
All of it.
Because your kidneys don’t distinguish between a prescription from a professor of medicine and a supplement sold in an elegant box.
They just deal with what’s in your bloodstream.
This brings me to a much bigger problem.
We have become very good at treating individual conditions. Hypertension? There’s a specialist. Joint pain? Another specialist. Weight management? There’s a clinic for that.
Each sees a problem and offers a solution.
But a human being isn’t a collection of unrelated problems.
A medication prescribed for one condition may worsen another. Two treatments may interact. Three may create a problem that none of them would cause alone.
And sometimes the side effect of one medication is mistaken for a new disease, which leads to another prescription.
There’s even a name for that: a prescribing cascade.
I have seen patients arrive with medication lists so long that the first consultation becomes an exercise in archaeology. We spend half the time working out why each drug was started, whether the original reason still exists, and whether anyone has reviewed the combination.
And that’s before we get to supplements.
People often assume that because something is described as natural, nutritional, or wellness, it can’t interfere with medical treatment.
Nature, unfortunately, has never signed such an agreement.
Some supplements have pharmacological effects. Some interact with prescription drugs. Some contain ingredients patients don’t realise they’re taking.
And vitamins aren’t exempt simply because they come in colourful bottles.
The problem isn’t that every additional medication is wrong. Many people need complex treatment, sometimes for life.
The problem is that every addition changes the whole picture.
And somebody needs to be looking at that picture.
Jim had access to excellent professionals. He could afford the consultations, the trainer, the lifestyle clinic, and the treatments.
What he didn’t have was someone who knew his full medical story, reviewed the entire list, and was prepared to ask whether the next addition was a good idea.
I keep coming back to the same thought.
Perhaps the most valuable medical decision isn’t always what to prescribe next.
Sometimes, it’s knowing what should never have been added in the first place.