Lost in Good Hands, part IV
### Lost in the Best Hands — The Final Chapter Modern medicine has never been more advanced. We have extraordinary specialists, remarkable diagnostic technologies and treatments that would have seemed miraculous just a generation ago. And yet, having access to the best medicine doesn't necessarily mean receiving the best healthcare. Throughout this four-part series, I've explored the paradoxes of modern healthcare: brilliant specialists working in silos, medications that accumulate without sufficient oversight, investigations that multiply, and a system that sometimes confuses doing more with doing better. In this final chapter, we look at the incentives behind that system — and ask a rather uncomfortable question: **What if the most valuable thing someone could do for your health was to tell you what you DON'T need?** And that brings us to the missing piece: **the Medical Fiduciary.**
# Lost in the Best Hands — Part IV
*The curious business of getting more healthcare than you need.*
Imagine paying £600 to see one of the most celebrated specialists in London.
You wait three weeks for the appointment. You've heard wonderful things about this doctor. Apparently, he's the best.
Forty minutes later, he looks at you and says:
"You're fine. Nothing to worry about. I wouldn't change anything."
That's it.
No prescription. No MRI. No blood tests. Not even a referral to another medical superstar.
Would you leave delighted?
Or would you wonder what, exactly, you just paid £600 for?
Welcome to one of the more uncomfortable realities of private medicine.
**Sometimes, the most valuable thing a doctor can give you is absolutely nothing.**
And that's a remarkably difficult product to sell.
Think about it. When you pay a small fortune for a consultation, you expect something tangible. A diagnosis, perhaps. A prescription. An investigation that will finally reveal the mysterious cause of your symptoms.
You want answers. Fair enough.
And the doctor wants to help.
Particularly the renowned specialist whose reputation has brought you through the door. Nobody enjoys disappointing a patient who has practically sold a kidney to secure an appointment.
So another investigation is ordered. Perhaps a referral. Something to demonstrate that the consultation has produced value.
I'm not suggesting that doctors knowingly prescribe unnecessary treatments to justify their fees. Most don't.
But medicine is practised by human beings, and human beings respond to expectations.
Doing something feels productive.
Saying "I don't think we need to do anything" requires confidence, judgement and, occasionally, considerable courage.
Especially when the patient is paying.
Now, let's introduce the third participant in this rather peculiar arrangement.
**Your health insurer.**
You pay your premiums. The insurer pays for covered services, subject to the policy's conditions.
A wonderfully simple arrangement.
And increasingly attractive in countries where public healthcare struggles with waiting times, limited choice and overloaded services.
More people turn to private healthcare. More consultations, investigations and outpatient treatments follow.
The figures are substantial. In Portugal, outpatient services accounted for approximately 45% of total healthcare expenditure in 2023, compared with 28% across the EU.
In the UK, private medical insurers paid a record £4 billion in claims in 2024.
Clearly, people are using their healthcare coverage.
And thank goodness they can.
But here's where things become interesting.
You visit a specialist. He requests investigations. Your insurer approves them.
Excellent!
You visit another specialist. More investigations. Also approved.
Wonderful service.
You feel reassured. Your doctors are being thorough. Your insurance is proving its worth.
Everyone seems happy.
Until renewal time.
Now, insurers are rather like casinos in one important respect.
**They don't build their business models around losing money.**
Depending on your policy and market, claims experience may influence your renewal premium. Even where your personal claims aren't directly used to calculate it, rising claims costs across the insured population eventually affect pricing.
Your premium goes up.
You complain, of course.
But you remember how useful the insurance was last year. All those consultations! All those investigations!
You certainly wouldn't want to lose that access.
So you renew.
Or you spend several evenings comparing policies, exclusions, networks and deductibles, trying to work out whether switching is worth the trouble.
A delightful hobby for someone who already has a full-time job.
And the cycle continues.
More healthcare activity creates more expenditure. More expenditure puts pressure on premiums. Higher premiums make us even more determined to get our money's worth.
Which, in healthcare, can mean wanting even more activity.
**Can you see the absurdity?**
We've created a situation where a patient may feel better served by receiving five investigations than by receiving one.
Even if one was all they needed.
And here's another uncomfortable truth.
Our healthcare systems are very good at recognising activity. Consultations delivered. Procedures performed. Investigations completed.
These are things we can count, bill for and measure.
But how do you measure the value of a doctor who spends an hour reviewing your medical history and concludes that you don't need another investigation?
Or the physician who notices that two specialists have prescribed medications that shouldn't be combined?
Or the one who prevents an unnecessary procedure?
These decisions require knowledge, experience, time and judgement. Sometimes considerably more than ordering another test.
Yet their value is much harder to demonstrate on an invoice.
This isn't a criticism of doctors. It's a question about what our healthcare systems have learned to reward.
**We have become very good at paying for what medicine does. Much less good at recognising the value of what good medicine prevents.**
And this is where I think we've confused two very different things.
Access to healthcare is valuable.
Consumption of healthcare isn't necessarily valuable.
Sometimes the best decision is another CT scan. Sometimes it's urgent surgery. Sometimes it's an extensive investigation involving several specialists.
And sometimes the best decision is simply:
"No. You don't need that."
Not because we're trying to save the insurer money.
Not because we're cutting corners.
But because someone has taken the time to understand your medical history, review the previous investigations, consider the recommendations and decide what actually makes sense.
Someone who can tell you that the blood tests requested yesterday were performed two weeks ago.
That the proposed CT won't answer any question that hasn't already been answered.
That a referral to yet another specialist is unlikely to change your treatment.
Or that the single investigation you really do need is one nobody has thought to request.
**That's not less healthcare. That's better healthcare.**
And the benefits can be rather surprising.
Fewer unnecessary investigations. Less time in waiting rooms. Less anxiety over incidental findings. Fewer opportunities for overtreatment.
Possibly lower costs, too.
Your insurer might even have fewer claims to pay.
God forbid.
But saving money isn't the point.
**The point is that someone should be protecting your health, not the volume of healthcare you consume.**
Throughout these four articles, I've written about brilliant doctors working in silos, prescriptions that accumulate, investigations that multiply, and a system that can confuse activity with value.
None of these problems requires bad doctors.
And none can be solved simply by finding an even better specialist.
What is missing is someone who sees the whole person. Someone who knows you, understands your medical history, follows your healthcare journey, challenges decisions when necessary and takes responsibility for keeping your interests at the centre of it all.
Not someone who replaces your doctors.
Someone who makes sure that everything being done *for you* is actually being done *in your best interests*.
**And that brings me to one word: FIDUCIARY.**
A fiduciary is someone entrusted to act in another person's best interests.
We accept the importance of this principle when managing wealth, investments and other valuable assets.
Why should our health be any different?
A **Medical Fiduciary** is the idea of a dedicated, professional and personalised advocate whose loyalty is to the person, not to the number of consultations, investigations or procedures performed.
Someone with the clinical knowledge to understand the options, the independence to question them, and the time to listen.
Someone who knows when you need the best specialist in the world.
And someone who can tell you, with equal confidence, when you don't need another specialist at all.
Because the purpose of healthcare was never to collect the best doctors, the most sophisticated investigations or the longest list of prescriptions.
**It was always to achieve the best possible outcome for you.**
And that is why, after everything we've discussed in *Lost in the Best Hands*, I believe the most important missing piece isn't another medical superstar.
**It's someone whose responsibility is to make sure you don't get lost among them.**